I migliori ristoranti di cucina italiana in Arezzo

24/10/2025: Sartù is a tiny hidden gem down an alley that you wouldn’t notice unless you appeared down and saw some tables outside on the steps. But boy am I happy I went in there thanks to my host and TripAdvisor. This is a one chef one server restaurant at least in the fall months. The menu had the most delectable titles of dishes. My ravioli dish with red sauce (a rarity in Cortona) and ricotta and other cheeses was titled something like “when everything good comes together and is nice.” Hilarious and true. I also had a dish with a round of pork covered in local vegetables that felt like it had been cooked in a stewing pot. It was the most delicious thing I’ve eaten all week. And not stereotypically Tuscan cuisine like most of the other restaurants in town, though they did have some staples like the Chianina and white beans.

24/09/2025: Wow—what a hidden gem! Sartu absolutely blew us away. The steak was simply delicious (paired perfectly with an order of carrots), but what really took things over the top was the deconstructed cannoli—hands down one of the most unique and memorable desserts I’ve ever had. The atmosphere is incredibly intimate, with only 18 seats total. We felt so welcomed, and even the chef came out personally to say hello, which made the experience extra special. It truly feels like dining in a private kitchen rather than a restaurant. If you’re lucky enough to snag a reservation, you’re in for a treat. Highly recommend—this is a place you’ll never forget.

08/03/2026: Excellent family-run restaurant. Everything is truly delicious.

18/10/2025: Delicious ice cream, beautiful outdoor space

26/09/2025: The best ice cream in the province

21/03/2026: Small but you eat well at lunch, more convenient in the evening the à la carte option is definitely more expensive.

16/03/2026: Best Chinese place I've ever eaten at and Lisa is also very nice and kind, if you pass by Sansepolcro go there

12/04/2026: Fantastic little store/bottega located in a tiny hamlet. You make your own sandwich (I mean schiacciata) from a list of ingredients . Just so you know: schiacciata is thin and crunchy, slightly oily. Finocchiona, artichokes, caramelized onion, mushroom cream: unbelievably good. Packed with bikers and families with kids. Love the large communal tables outside the steep pavement. They also have a few tables inside.

16/03/2026: A hidden gem: the little places I like. It's a shame it was packed, and then my son's opinion of the schiacciata! Small, hidden, and far away, but we're not ruling out returning!

08/03/2026: Everything was delicious and the service was top notch. Matteo is the best restaurateur in Talla and the surrounding area.

20/11/2025: Everything was excellent, from the fettuccine with duck ragù to the mixed roasts with potatoes, and the homemade desserts. The atmosphere was informal and welcoming. Highly recommended.

12/04/2026: I returned for a snack dinner. The various cured meats, cheeses, pickles, and desserts are all excellent and of high quality. Unfortunately, this is no longer the case for the schiacciata and bread, which, in my opinion, are a key part of the overall offering. For this reason, the stars have gone from 5 to 3. The staff is always friendly, and the atmosphere, while informal, is clean and welcoming. Prices have gone up, but it remains good value.

07/04/2026: Historic local business with high-quality baked goods and typical Tuscan products! Professional, knowledgeable, and courteous staff, the best you'll find in the Casentino area, definitely recommended!

03/05/2026: This restaurant is simply exceptional! Across the board: food, wine (not a large, but a fabulous list), and atmosphere. Consistently one of the very best meals we have in Tuscany

24/04/2026: A very good restaurant, excellent Italian cuisine! I will gladly return. The atmosphere was a little quiet, but we came at lunchtime so it was calm.

22/03/2026: We had dinner at Maria's. The food was excellent, but it's a shame the place wasn't heated enough.

13/03/2026: Fiorentina da Dio....the queen indeed

12/09/2025: An amazing restaurant with charming service and excellent and special food, unlike any other restaurant in the area.

06/09/2025: La Tana degli Orsi is a small but meticulously maintained restaurant in the heart of Casentino. Simone and Caterina are true masters of hospitality and passionate advocates of high-quality products, especially local ones, which they always showcase.

18/04/2026: If I could give it 0 stars, I would. Terrible service, incredibly slow, rude waiters. It took more than 45 minutes to eat an appetizer; we arrived at 2:00 and the main course never showed up. We got up and left. We also had a 1.5-year-old baby. Terrible experience!

25/03/2026: I was there last year. The food was friendly and the meat was delicious. I'll be back soon.

06/04/2026: Classy environment, very friendly and competent staff. Highly recommended.

08/03/2026: We had higher expectations 🤦🏻‍♀️not recommended for those who love to eat well!!!

09/04/2026: A wonderful stay, everything was perfect. The gourmet restaurant is really lovely. The chef is very friendly.

16/03/2026: A truly stunning and peaceful location. The structure is of the highest quality, immersed in the Tuscan countryside, with a beautiful pool for the summer months and absolute tranquility. Perfect for high-level ceremonies, weddings, confirmations, or communions. High-quality cuisine, both meat and seafood, with intense Mediterranean flavors. Prices are high, but as we know, quality comes at a price. A truly excellent place.

13/12/2025: A disappointing experience despite the positive reviews. It's a small osteria in a hamlet just outside Arezzo. We sat down for lunch; we weren't given a menu; instead, the owner/waiter verbally listed a selection of three or four first courses and four second courses. The quality was average to low, and the fact that everything was served within minutes of ordering suggests it was all precooked. The ravioli with meat sauce were decent, but the rabbit, fried long beforehand and then reheated in the oven, was inedible. Green beans with sauce were served on the side, but they were probably lemon-flavored beforehand. Nearly €60 for a first course, two second courses, two side dishes, two desserts, and a bottle of water wouldn't be too much, but forget about the flavors of Tuscan cuisine.

13/12/2025: Delicious food and impeccable, friendly, and professional service. It's a shame about the parking and location! I highly recommend it; I'll definitely be back.

23/11/2025: Ristorantino Madú in Sansepolcro is a true gem! The atmosphere is welcoming, and the staff is friendly and welcoming. The cuisine is simple yet delicious, using top-quality ingredients and traditional Tuscan recipes revisited with a touch of creativity. The vegetarian and meat dishes are both delicious, and the prices are more than reasonable. The service is impeccable, with the staff always ready to offer advice and accommodate guests' requests. If you're in Sansepolcro, don't miss the opportunity to try Ristorantino Madú! It's a place where you can eat well and feel the authentic Tuscan atmosphere.

14/11/2025: Very nice and professional. Excellent food and beautiful location.