I migliori ristoranti di cucina italiananella città Poppi della Arezzo

10/08/2026: If you're looking for a break from the summer heat, this location nestled in the Casentino Forests is perfect. But if you're looking for a good lunch, things are different. We order a mixed grill for two and grilled vegetables. The portion for two immediately seems paltry (2 pancettas, 2 sausages, 4 very small ribs, and a cut of red meat). The worst comes when we try to eat the red meat: rubbery, tough, impossible even to cut with carving knives. We report the incident privately to the waiter. His reaction? He returns with two spoons, takes the piece of meat from the cutting board, and leaves without saying a word or offering an alternative. When we get the bill, we mention the incident to the owner, who simply dismisses us with a curt "Strange." No remedy, no apology, zero professionalism in handling a more than legitimate complaint. A necessary review to warn future customers.

10/08/2026: Lovely place, great food, and excellent value. Super friendly and helpful staff. I'll definitely be back.

15/04/2026: We spent three magical nights at I Tre Baroni, taking advantage of the three-night package that included a room with a spa, a private massage, a private excursion, and a tasting dinner at the Mater restaurant (a truly special place!). What can I say? From the very beginning, Gessica was incredibly kind and available to answer all our questions and clarify any doubts, even before our stay, personalizing our experience. When we arrived, we immediately felt welcomed. The room was gorgeous, very spacious, with a spectacular view of the Casentinesi Forests National Park. The room was spotless, with a hot tub and sauna. The private excursion with Stefano was a wonderful experience: his guide was invaluable in helping us fully appreciate the wonders of the park! The dinners at the restaurant were also highly recommended: the atmosphere is meticulously maintained and welcoming, the service impeccable, and you have the opportunity to sample the local flavors, expertly cooked and served. We hope to return soon, and thanks again to Gessica and Messan for their hospitality and professionalism! Alice & Genna

13/04/2026: An unacceptable experience. I was looking for the silence of Casentino, but I found chaos. It all started with a lack of transparency: I booked a suite with a sauna, but upon check-in, they gave me a different room without telling me, hoping I wouldn't notice. Only after I protested was I granted a change; there's no point in calling it an upgrade, since the room offered lacked the booked amenities and was aesthetically inferior. The rest was a crescendo of poor service: - Technical: The suite shower was unusable due to lack of pressure. - Acoustic: A sleepless night due to the roar of the whirlpool tubs below (until midnight). I didn't call again just to avoid waking my partner, who, after various mix-ups, had only managed to sleep thanks to earplugs. - Construction site: Awake at 8:00 a.m. on Sunday, hammering on the roof and weaving between construction trucks to get to breakfast. Work was kept quiet until arrival despite a recent reservation (24 hours in advance). The 50% discount was obtained only after a firm discussion. The initial disrespect and the construction-like environment are incompatible with a high-end hotel. Not recommended.

04/07/2026: A royal lunch! It's been years since I've eaten so well! The place is lovely, a great place to escape the summer heat and enjoy a wonderful view. I had the guinea fowl with Marsala, celeriac, and pan-fried zucchini. Everything was delicious, tasty, and perfectly cooked. I finished the bread and cleaned the plates. Then I gave in to the temptation of the very kind Mrs. Mariangela and had a homemade cherry dessert made with the lightest sweet yogurt, a worthy end to a royal meal. Highly recommended.

01/06/2026: Quality food, authentic cuisine, friendly family atmosphere. Prices are a bit high.

27/05/2026: They had a written reservation for months and simply ignored our group of 25 people with children.

23/05/2026: Worst Place ever. Messed up our reservation wasn’t able to solve it. Left the entire group outside ignored.