I migliori ristoranti di cucina italiana in Siena

09/11/2025: AD MENTULA CANIS Just finished eating at this place. Eating is a strong word. My companion had pici cacio e pepe, which were good enough if a little small in quantity, and a simple green salad (you can't go wrong with a salad). The problem arose with me: I had a cheeseburger. It was supposed to have Tuscan cheese inside, I think pecorino or rigatino... THERE WAS NO TRACE OF IT. The bread was dry and hard to bite, the meat lacking even a hint of salt, and what's worse, it was absolutely very thin. On the other hand, it was full of tomato and lettuce. I found a small smear of red sauce on top, but it was completely absorbed by the moisture-deficient bread. I almost choked on it several times. Making a sandwich shouldn't be this difficult... and yet. I've never had a worse sandwich; I left almost all of it. I didn't ask for a change because I quickly realized that was the standard anyway. It was well priced, though: 18 euros! With some fries on the side, and luckily I at least ate those. TO BE FORGOTTEN Unfortunately, this review will be of little use; these are simply tourist traps.

30/10/2025: Completely inhospitable staff. We had been looking forward to trying the gnudi for a couple days. We arrived at 6:55 in the pouring rain with our 4 year old and 10 month old. The one gentleman couldn’t have been more rude. He insisted we wait outside in the rain for 5 more minutes. This restaurant doesn’t deserve your patronage.

06/11/2025: The Taglierone for 2 was excellent, except for the tagliatelle with wild boar, and the ribollita was practically a minestrone. Overall, it was acceptable.

04/11/2025: very high prices for the disgusting quality of the food, I had a poor first course and saw a customer next to me who had double my portion (same first course) in the end it seems like the staff laughed at us

24/09/2025: I've entered the place by chance during a rainy day in Siena. When i sat and order, i've looked for its reviews on maps and i was a bit worried. But in the end, i was totally surprised! I worded a caccio e pepe that was delicious, and was properly attended.

23/09/2025: Terrible place, the food was not amazing, really small portions, and we got charged for some extras and the restaurant refused to remove them from the bill. When we asked to ammend the bill they made a big scene

12/07/2025: Ottimo per un crostone e pera pausa al fresco del bosco accanto a Gargano. Presenti anche piatti più elaborati e vendita di formaggi ed altro al suo interno. Da provare

26/04/2025: La posizione sarebbe anche buona con un bel panorama, ma il personale è veramente pessimo, la gentilezza e l’educazione non sanno neanche cosa siano. Uno dei peggiori locali in cui sia mai stato. Sconsiglio vivamente.

04/06/2025: Café frío y débil. Yogur servido en vasos de plástico sin sabor. Evita desayunar. No puedo comentar sobre otras comidas.

02/06/2025: La poca cortesia che io ho ricevuto ieri dal personale è stata quasi al limite della maleducazione. Capisco che l’1 o il 2 giugno possa esserci stata molta affluenza e che il barista potesse essere stanco/stressato ma entrare nel bar per gustare un buon caffè al bancone e dover andar via con l’amaro in bocca della rispostaccia ricevuta è stato davvero poco spiacevole.

20/08/2025: As a celiac, I was able to personally verify what I'd been told over the phone: the attention paid to preventing contamination was indeed high and meticulous. Overall, I was completely satisfied with the experience and I think I'll gladly return, also thanks to the kindness and courtesy of the chef, who made me feel at ease when choosing the menu. A heartfelt thank you.

10/08/2025: I don't recommend eating here...low-quality appetizer, old raw meat, found a piece of steel wool in the pasta. The chef was very dirty.

18/07/2025: We ordered pizzas, which were overall average. My disappointment was the tiramisu, which literally didn't live up to its name, as it lacked biscuits: at this point, call it mascarpone cream, huh? At least the staff was courteous.

24/08/2025: Excellent A Liège coffee for €5 Super friendly owner

14/07/2025: ⭐☆☆☆☆ (0/5 if I could) I genuinely wish I had something good to say about this place, but unfortunately, the best thing I had here was the water. The ice cream left a strange and unpleasant aftertaste that made me question the ingredients. On top of that, the employee seemed visibly unhappy—maybe the bad quality ice cream is getting to them too. All in all, I wouldn’t recommend this shop to anyone. Definitely not coming back.

27/07/2025: Apart from its prime location this place is just a tourist trap. No italian person working there. We had three different plates of pasta and they were tasteless. The tartufo in one plate was like eating a chewing gum. Totally disappointed! Will never go there another time.

23/07/2025: You can tell a lot about an establishment by their restroom. Unfortunately, we had already ordered when I saw the filth and stench. Our steak was pure fat, and the Tuscan soup was all bread. I asked for a box to take the food to our hotel because I felt bad wasting it, and the Romanian manager said it’s not possible. She was awful and rude. I’m only giving 2 stars because our Moroccan waiter was wonderful. There are so many wonderful real Italian restaurants in the Piazza, avoid this one!

14/10/2025: Servers are slow and just stand around talking and ignore multiple tables who are wanting to order. Drinks are more expensive and not as good as nearby restaurants. Cant recommend, waste of money and time due to slow servers

10/10/2025: The service at this place is terrible. We went for dinner because we were staying at the hotel and there weren't many options available. They served us horribly; they refused to clean the table we chose. They waited on us in a hurry, and we spent almost 80 euros on two plates of pasta and two plates of baked potatoes for four people, two wines, and some soft drinks. I don't recommend it.

27/10/2025: Extremely bad! And the toilets are terrible!

21/10/2025: Visited October 19, 2025 Visited Siena on a bus tour This restaurant is located right in front of Piazza del Campo Since it offers a stunning view of the piazza, the prices are steep. Consider it a seat fee. A glass of classic wine is €7 A 500cc beer is €6.50 It's romantic.

04/08/2025: assegno "2 pallini" solo perché la terrazza merita.. Il Resto da evitare chiediamo 1 fiorentina, questa arriva e si presenta anche bene come cottura ( cottura al sangue) arriva il momento di tagliarla ed assaggiarla... immangiabile, la carne nonostante che fosse al sangue era stopposa non si riusciva a letteralmente a mangiarla. Avvisiamo la cameriera che ci risponde "non dovete dirlo a me ma dovete dirlo dentro" Non ci siamo proprio... un posto con delle potenzialità sprecato in questo modo rapporto qualità/prezzo : pessimo

21/07/2025: Posto molto turistico, cibo caro e di scarsa qualità, la fiorentina era immangiabile (dura e piena di nervi), è stato fatto presente alla signora che ci ha servito ma al momento del conto abbiamo pagato prezzo pieno, di sicuro non ci torneremo. Sconsigliato.

08/11/2025: Very good service and excellent food

01/11/2025: The most delicious white wine I drank during this trip 🥂

26/10/2025: The servers are rude, they wouldn't let us sit down even when the restaurant was empty, just because there were 5 of us and we had 2 coffees, the kids didn't drink coffee, the toilet was smelly and dirty, and the coffee was for tourists who don't want to come back.

20/10/2025: The advertised porchetta on the outside turns out to be a mini sandwich from the day before with a bit of porchetta inside that's all fat and pepper. It's all prepared by hand and costs €6.50. A small glass of red wine from the Bag, quite tart, costs €3. To top it off, there's no receipt. It's fine to be a tourist magnet, in fact it wouldn't be, but local customers are guaranteed not to return.

16/09/2025: We arrived in San Casciano dei Bagni around 2:00 PM and, before continuing our visit, we stopped at this place. Some friends of ours had arrived shortly before and had ordered platters of cured meats and cheeses with wine: decent quality, but the bill was already disproportionate (€30 per person for four people, with two small platters and three-quarters of wine). Knowing those prices, we chose the simplest option: a porchetta sandwich. Never was a worse choice. The bread was hard, the porchetta was extremely salty, poorly cut, and with an aftertaste that left serious doubts about its freshness. The wine, however, tasted like water diluted with cardboard: undrinkable. In the end, for 15 sandwiches and 3 liters of wine, we found ourselves spending €20 each. Unacceptable. I've traveled to many villages in Italy and have rarely come across such a mockery. It's not just the high prices (which are reasonable in a tourist town), but the terrible quality of the food and the total lack of respect for the customer. My only regret is that I didn't even have the courage to take photos. An experience to forget. I absolutely do not recommend this place: a real scam for visitors.