I migliori ristoranti di cucina pesce in Toscana

08/03/2025: Cibo di buona qualità in un menù con un numero di portate giusto per avere sempre materie prime fresche. L’atmosfera del locale è un pò tanto classica per i miei gusti.

14/02/2025: L’attesa per i piatti è stata leggermente lunga, ma comunque bella location e nell’atmosfera per San Valentino!!

07/08/2025: Eccellente pranzo e soprattutto una cena superlativa con l'atmosfera esterna che ti fa sentire coccolato con la super gentilezza di tutto il personale. Ottimi crudi di mare freschissimo e presentato in modo scenografico. A prestissimo!

26/07/2025: Rimasto veramente deluso da tutto. Personale non professionale, cibo molto deludente con un piatto di crudo da 60€ scarso e non curato con 2 tartare di bassissima qualità. Sono andato lì in base alle altre recensioni e non capisco dove possono esserci tutte quelle qualità lette. Spero per loro che sia stata solo una serata negativa

16/09/2025: I can't recommend this place. The male waitress was friendly, but her English wasn't very good. She seemed a bit fidgety, and I even got into a heated argument with the manager. The food simply wasn't good enough for the price. It was served carelessly on large plates.

05/09/2025: This isn't our first time at this restaurant, but it's always a pleasure! Not only for their excellent dishes, including excellent fried fish and delicious pizza! But also for the owners, who, besides being very kind, are above all down-to-earth! And this makes the price seem a bit out of place, as it's certainly not cheap, but it's justified by the excellent quality of the dishes! And the location.

10/09/2025: I stumbled upon it by chance during a business trip. The pizza was undercooked and the dough was nothing special, nothing like "real" Neapolitan pizza. But the worst part was that after a terrible meal, only at checkout was I told they don't accept electronic payments, only cash. I therefore had to pay for the dinner out of pocket, because untraceable payments are not reimbursed by the company.

25/05/2025: I'm considering a home delivery of five pizzas (three with tomato sauce and two without) from this place, which was a few hundred meters from my apartment. Delivery was almost on time, but the pizzas arrived cold, probably because they weren't in the lunchbox. The pizzas were full of liquid, which leaked out during delivery, soaking the boxes and the pizza base. The tomato sauce tasted excessively sweet, so much so that it could have been confused with ketchup. Of the pizzas I ordered, the only ones I'd save were the white-based ones.

28/08/2025: An experience I definitely won't repeat!! €100 spent in the absolute worst way!! Bland appetizers, unclassifiable first courses, penne with scampi cream (a cream that actually made from 1/2 liter of cream?!?) with a scampi hidden at the bottom of a 400g plate of penne and shrimp. Spaghetti with crabmeat, undercooked and with a flavor reminiscent of pre-cooked sauces from discount stores. I was hoping to finish on a high note with fried shrimp and calamari, but unfortunately it turned out to be quite disappointing: limp, full of oil, and the shrimp definitely had a strange flavor. Alas, in a place as beautiful as Porto Ercole, I wasn't expecting a restaurant like this; it deserves better.

22/08/2025: An unpretentious restaurant in a very characteristic location. We dined here one evening in August and ordered only fresh fish, recommended by the legendary Ivo, the charming owner. Overall, we appreciated the home-style cooking. We had a great time, and kudos to this family.

19/07/2025: Cibo buono ma ho cenato da sola nonostante fossimo in coppia. Arriva il mio antipasto e dopo 15 Min quello del mio compagno. Poi arriva il mio piatto principale e mezz'ora dopo quello del mio compagno...per me queste cose sono inaccettabili. Non tornerò, ovviamente

15/07/2025: Il locale è posto sulla passeggiata a mare, in posizione strategica dal punto di vista della visibilità, e si presenta molto bene, con tavoli ordinati e ben apparecchiati. Il nostro è stato un pranzo veloce, perché eravamo in transito e la lunga percorrenza che ancora ci attendeva quel giorno non consigliava di fare un pasto impegnativo. Giudicare un ristorante sulla base delle semplici insalate che abbiamo consumato mi pare ingiusto, però va detto che nel loro genere ci sono parse tutto sommato deludenti, non fosse altro per il rapporto qualità-prezzo... Dato comunque che l'ambiente risulta attraente, ci torneremo, magari per provare la pizza e i piatti di pesce.

25/09/2025: Definitely good food, honest prices, good service

01/09/2025: A wonderful dining experience with a breathtaking view overlooking the sea. Thanks to our friend Francesca and Tommaso, who served us with such warmth and friendliness. We'll be back next year (God willing).

03/06/2025: Top environment for ease of reaching, beauty of the location, hospitality and attention towards families and customers in general and quality of the gastronomic offer. The pizza is notable...one of the best I've ever eaten...highly recommended

12/05/2025: The pici all'aglione are excellent, the only drawback is the coffee and water at 3 euros each.

09/05/2025: Antipasto diciamo discreto… al quanto il primo, oltretutto vi era scritto ripieno all’ astice… di astice nemmeno l’ombra… grigliata alquanto secca e insapore…!

31/08/2025: We were with my mom in July for almost a week, they were very very very kind to us, we ate very well every time we went to the restaurant, the owners are 3 brothers, one kinder and cooler than the other, and they have a very big differential, in addition to their friendliness, you can stay on the beach as long as you want, it's not like other beach resorts where it closes at 6 or 7 pm and they invite you to leave, here you can stay and that's great because if you like to watch the sunset, which is around 9 at night, you can do it, we will return, highly recommended.

25/08/2025: The worst restaurant—the reviews speak for themselves, if only we'd read them beforehand. Stay away from this restaurant.

30/09/2025: My boyfriend and I had some fried food for lunch, each one better than the last. The portions and prices were fair, everything was delicious and easy to digest!

06/07/2025: Bella esperienza.. frittura buonissima.servita in modo semplice ma ci sta con il luogo...porzioni giuste e prezzi onesti..servizio tra i migliori dell isola che non eccelle in ospitalità.. grazie abbiamo replicato e se torniamo sicuramente ci rivedremo

06/08/2025: I recommend it to everyone. The staff was very friendly. They recommended a very good wine. We didn't have a full dinner... we ordered the calamari, which was fresh and delicious, and the portions were just right.

24/07/2025: Rude and impolite staff The worst experience of my life The worst ever

12/10/2025: Dropped in for lunch and oh my God they do woodfired pizzas. Also share a Caprese salad. Food was divine, pizzas were on point. Definitely recommend if you're in this area.

24/09/2025: Risotto 18€ rice 5 mussels 3 clams 2 shrimps and squid you have to go fishing for them🤔

08/09/2025: If you want to eat well, stop in front of this place... and find another. One star is already too many. Leaving aside the rude and annoyed attitude of the waiters, the real problem was the organization: after more than an hour from ordering, we were asked what we had ordered. This speaks volumes about the restaurant's seriousness. When we asked for an explanation and to finally have our dishes, we were told to wait another 20 minutes. The result? We left without having eaten practically anything.

02/09/2025: Let's talk about the color of the light! We had to wear sunglasses, the light was so cold and intense. The food, however, was excellent!

04/10/2025: I strongly advise against it. They made us sit on uncomfortable benches without cushions, the waiters were extremely slow in serving us, the ham was so salty we sent it back to the kitchen, and the portions were relatively small for the price. Other customers that evening were clearly complaining about the service and the slowness of bringing the bill.

14/09/2025: Tratoria Tre Stelle aptly named to reflect its rating. Very pleasant atmosphere on the road terrace but failed to follow through with our meal - a bowl of gnocchi with scampi. The gnocchi was served way too hot not to have been nuked into a mush. The taste was lost after the first mouthful as the rest of the meal was spent icing your palate. Service was inviting with a gentle charm. Pity but the hospitality industry is such that you only get one chance to entice your clients back.