Before booking this place, I was honestly intrigued, especially by the name. Then I looked at the website and the reviews, and so I booked. I have to say, it's a small, excellent restaurant run by a truly kind and knowledgeable gentleman. He exudes passion and explains the dishes with great care. I ordered the pappa al pomodoro, and I admit that before coming here, I didn't even know what it was... And I have to say, I loved it. My wife ordered the ribbolita, another delicacy. What can I say? If you want to eat truly well, this is the place for you, both for the variety of delicacies and, last but not least, the very reasonable prices.
Andrea
.
08 Ottobre 2025
10,0
We stumbled across it by chance. It's lovingly run and offered us a comfortable spot during the storm. Great food, high quality, reasonable prices, and friendly service.
X Anadu
.
25 Settembre 2025
10,0
Everything excellent, highly recommended
Paolo Travasco
.
17 Settembre 2025
10,0
My wife and I had the pleasure of discovering this restaurant in Castiglione della Pescaia, appreciating the location, quality, and service. Excellent rating for the dishes, carefully selected in keeping with Tuscan tradition. Congratulations!
Pietro Cavalieri
.
11 Settembre 2025
10,0
What can I say... friendly staff, very fast. Excellent food from the bruschetta to the dessert, everything delicious and authentic. In one word: EXCELLENT. I RECOMMEND
Nick name
.
07 Settembre 2025
10,0
We had lunch here last Sunday. Excellent food, excellent service, and reasonable prices. The menu features traditional dishes made with quality ingredients. Ribollita, pappa al pomodoro, Maremma tuna, Maremma buffalo mozzarella alla castiglionese, wild boar ragù—EVERYTHING EXCELLENT!!!!!
...and then the "cacio e pepe" dessert, a delicious surprise.
Stefy Salma
.
02 Settembre 2025
10,0
I had an excellent dining experience here. The burrata with capers and anchovies was absolutely delightful – creamy, perfectly balanced, and with just the right touch of briny intensity. The tonno al Chianti was equally impressive. Both dishes were prepared with great attention to detail and felt both authentic and refined. Highly recommended for anyone looking to enjoy truly memorable Italian flavors.
Aleksander Siniarski
.
02 Settembre 2025
10,0
I had the pleasure of dining at the Riserva Naturale restaurant in Castiglione della Pescaia, and I can say it was a truly memorable experience.
Quality of Raw Materials
One of this restaurant's strong points is undoubtedly the quality of its ingredients. Many of the ingredients used in the dishes are grown directly by the owner, resulting in fresh and authentic flavors. It's clear that great attention is paid to the selection of ingredients, and this makes all the difference in the final result.
Excellent Service
The staff is always friendly and attentive. Each member of staff was helpful and ready to recommend the daily specials, making the atmosphere even more welcoming. It's rare to find such attentive service, which manages to make every customer feel special.
Ideal Location
Finally, the restaurant's location is another highlight. It's close to the center, but not in the busiest area, allowing you to enjoy a quiet meal without the noise and bustle typical of more crowded areas. This makes the experience even more enjoyable, allowing you to savor each dish in a relaxed atmosphere.
In conclusion, I highly recommend Riserva Naturale to anyone visiting Castiglione della Pescaia. The combination of fresh ingredients, impeccable service, and a peaceful setting make it the perfect place for an unforgettable dinner.
Matteo Bellotti
.
29 Agosto 2025
10,0
Qui ti senti a casa accolti da un padrone di casa eccezionale,uno staff super gentile abbiamo mangiato un ottimo tagliere di affettati e formaggi e una marmellata top,la panzanella rivisitata buonissima un pinzimonio un attimo da rivedere ,la trippa fatta molto bene, una ricotta super buona che dire vi rimane solo di andare a provare….il locale è’stato ristrutturato e ha un sacco di cose buone anche da poter portare a casa.
Cinzia P
.
08 Giugno 2025
10,0
Locale non molto grande ma con grandi piatti.
La maggior parte degli ingredienti preparati da loro o selezionati da produttori locali.
Staff veramente cordiale, un plauso al proprietario che intrattiene la clientela con i suoi modi di fare amichevoli.
Se disponibile provate la pannacotta di pecora con marmellata di fragole...voto 10
Filippo C
.
25 Aprile 2025
10,0