Booked well in advance and requested table on the terrace which was nice. Food was good, but price and special entre was more than most mains and of course you didn't know this, water and wine wasn't always refilled in a timely manner. Declined water and then was asked again and pretty much forced to order 4Euro water, when we had already ordered a full bottle of wine. The most disappointing part of the experience was when paying we were forced to leave a tip with the waiter saying tip cash or card, when we tried to simply pay the bill total the waiter added 10% tip to an already very expensive bill. Considering we had just had dinner at Don Giovanni in positano the night before which had amazing views, no pressure to tip, no water forced or coperto charge was left quite disappointed with the service and the experience at Da Gemma. Next time would try a different restaurant in amalfi.
Rosemary Orderud
.
01 Settembre 2024
6,0
We liked it very much, especially because they brought the sea bass after cleaning it, and because of the polite behavior of the waiters, it can definitely be preferred. It is necessary to make a reservation online in advance
Damla Sekban
.
31 Agosto 2024
10,0
Food quality is excellent, location outstanding, terrace is a fabulous place to eat, especially since they added a tarp. Wine list is very extensive. Service was slow and inattentive - we had to pour our own water and wine almost the entire evening.
I constantly felt I was being upsold on my wine choice.
We didn't see a server after our meal was served. Had to finally just go ask for a check - we weren't even offered dessert which is shocking given how much they were trying to upsell the wine.
Overall a very nice experience - less the poor service
rbtvwestfall
.
29 Agosto 2024
8,0
On a terrace above the chaos of the street, a truly wonderful old restaurant
Very kind welcome from a young Djia woman? (Not sure of the spelling) and the sommelier
We followed their recommendations and the shrimp risotto is unforgettable
Everything was perfect!
elisabeth Lando
.
25 Agosto 2024
10,0
Very good experience of Campania and seafood cuisine. We really appreciated the availability that was granted to us to celebrate my daughter's birthday.
Francesco Zenga
.
25 Agosto 2024
8,0
Food Amazing, definitely a taste of Amalfi. I missed a bit of service attention as we had 2 bottles of champagne and both were " warm" we had to ask twice for ice, and the attention was not up to standards.
Overall food made our night and they have a little selection of home made biscuits and sweets with our coffee.
Jos Bandes
.
24 Agosto 2024
10,0
Great food. Service not up to standard and nice atmosphere. We had a good dinner but we ordered 2 bottles of champagne and both were warm! Place like this for the prices they have should be everything on top.
Romeo Bucciarelli
.
24 Agosto 2024
6,0
It was a very good meal on the terrace of the Da Gemma restaurant. The service was impeccable and the servers were very friendly. It is a shame that it had to rain but that remains the weather circumstances. In addition, the dishes are very tasty, especially the pasta with truffle as well as the lemon dessert.
On the other hand, according to some members of my family, the black pasta (I think it was the dish of the day) was rather bland and lacked taste.
Otherwise, we spent a pleasant evening in your magnificent restaurant!
Alexandre Huynh
.
22 Agosto 2024
10,0
Like everything in Amalfi, very expensive! Disproportionate. The food was very good, the balcony was nice. And it was empty.
Marcelo Maia
.
18 Agosto 2024
8,0
non e' cambiato negli anni, terrazza con vista passeggio sempre superaffollata, servizio gentile e veloce, menu' tradizionale di pesce con molto crudo, abbastanza caro , frittura non eccezionale
gian carlo d
.
14 Agosto 2024
6,0