We went to Pizzeria Vecchio Mulino on Valentine's Day 💘, so it was quite busy, but despite that, they seated us right away, without a long wait. The waiters were kind and helpful, and the service was truly excellent, which isn't a given on such a busy evening.
We started with a delicious appetizer, albeit a bit limited in quantity: 2 buffalo mozzarellas with Parma ham, the truly delicious one, clearly of high quality.
The pizzas (2 buffalo mozzarella margheritas) were very good, probably the best we've had in Caltanissetta so far. That said, they're still a bit unremarkable—good, yes, but without that extra something that makes you go crazy with joy… you know what I mean 😉
One sore point about the dessert: good, but very lacking. There was supposed to be a mix of fruit (kiwi, strawberries, etc.), but instead they only brought us strawberries, which was a bit disappointing compared to expectations.
The price is a bit high, but considering it's Valentine's Day, I can easily understand that.
The real downside, however, is the seating: tables were too crowded together, with people constantly passing by and the risk of jostling, which somewhat spoiled the atmosphere.
Overall, it was a wonderful, fun, and enjoyable experience, even if it wasn't perfect. With a few more improvements to the space and desserts, it would easily be 5 stars.
Davide
.
15 Febbraio 2026
8,0