Osteria del Mare già il Votapentole In Castiglione della pescaia

"Excellent taste, a smile on the face of the service" Osteria del Mare is one of those places where the cuisine truly speaks for itself. The dishes express the region with surprising clarity: ultra-fresh fish, top-quality ingredients, and a kitchen that enhances every flavor without ever overpowering it. From crudités to expertly crafted pasta dishes, to main courses that exude the aroma of real seafood, each course demonstrates a care and expertise hard to find elsewhere. The atmosphere is pleasant, refined without being pretentious, and contributes to the atmosphere typical of the best Tuscan seafood osterias: authentic, welcoming, and relaxed. A small, constructive suggestion, born from the overall appreciation: an extra smile and a pinch of empathy from the owner would make the experience truly impeccable. The quality of the cuisine deserves equally warm service, and it wouldn't take much to transform an excellent lunch into a perfect memory. In any case, Osteria del Mare remains a highly recommended stop for those seeking authentic flavors and seafood cuisine that never disappoints.

Christmas lunch!!!! Highly recommended!!!!!!

Simple menu, mostly fish dishes, very large wine list.

It couldn't be better - the food (fish!), wine (Vermentino) and service were perfect! A dream.

Excellent quality food, everything was delicious

Excellent value for money. Impeccable.

Arriving for the first sitting on a Sunday at 7:30 PM, we ate calmly, albeit with a few heavy eyes from the less-than-professional staff. The appetizer consisted of a shrimp cocktail, a dish with a mayonnaise made into a pink sauce with tomato sauce, which seemed to come straight from a horror movie: completely unconnected and therefore runny, a very simple dish but made by someone who doesn't seem to be a professional. Another appetizer was a seafood pan-fried dish, lacking in flavor. The first courses made up for it, excellent both the black linguine with mussels and especially the ravioli with octopus ragù. The second course we shared was also excellent, octopus on creamed potatoes, made even better by the confit cherry tomatoes that gave the dish a nice balance. Dessert was always shared, a "chocolate fondant," also made by someone who, in my opinion, forgot to bake it too long, as we found it very dry.

For a dear friend's birthday, I had dinner at this restaurant. We sampled a selection of mixed appetizers (the octopus lampredotto sandwich was exceptional!) and a first or second course each. I must say, I ate very well! The fish was excellent quality, with generous portions, at least in my opinion. The attention to detail was also evident in the plating, and the staff was truly friendly and knowledgeable. Congratulations!

An excellent restaurant with a menu featuring the freshest seafood, served with delicacy, flavor, and elegant plating. Tables are well-spaced to ensure privacy, and the space is well-soundproofed for perfect conviviality. Excellent service and great professionalism. Extremely friendly and helpful staff. Excellent value for money. Booking well in advance is recommended, as immediate seating is difficult due to the high demand.

Five of us had dinner at this pleasant restaurant in the center of Castiglione. Excellent dishes, from raw fish to exquisite tuna, shrimp, and octopus. The limited markup on wines is appreciated, allowing you to pair your dishes without breaking the bank. Absolutely reasonable prices.