Crowded for a weekday afternoon but the line did move.
Raspberry - fresh and had raspberry bits
Pistachio - could taste real pistachios, not overly sweet or bitter
White chocolate crunch - my favorite. Loved the crunch bits
Mango cheesecake - decent but maybe a tad too cheesy or milky for sticky gelato for my personal liking
Generous portions and reasonable price. Friendly service and nice retro ambience.
Natalie Vera
.
06 Luglio 2026
10,0
Best ice cream in UES! The staff is amazing - always friendly, always courteous. Can get very busy in the evenings, but always worth the wait.
Fara Tolib
.
05 Luglio 2026
10,0
Very good gelato; as an Italian, I genuinely appreciate Anita Gelato and consider it one of the better options in NYC.
I stopped by this location today for a large takeaway. Unfortunately, my experience started on the wrong foot, as the first staff member who served me came across as quite rude and she focused more on explaining what could not be done rather than offering alternatives.
Thankfully, Eduardo stepped in and completely turned the experience around. He was kind, accommodating, and made sure I left satisfied. A big thank you to him; I only wish more servers approached customer service the way he does. I also sincerely hope he gets to keep the tip I gave him, as he truly earned it.
Charif Gnatta
.
03 Luglio 2026
6,0
Great quality and super friendly service. There are tons of interesting flavors, and the staff is happy to give samples and recommendations. I wasn’t going to get anything, but I tried a vegan chocolate cookie flavor, and it was so good I had to get a scoop. And the scoops are not cheap, but they have been really generous, so, this would be a perfect time to share a scoop with someone.
Clearly my opinion isn’t unique, as there was a line of people out the door, but it moves fast enough.
Douglas NY
.
30 Giugno 2026
10,0
Great gelato selection and Great customer service
Steven Corniel
.
29 Giugno 2026
10,0
This truly Italian gelato house has a wide variety of flavors that blows away the others that are mediocre & overcharge with smaller portions from Van Leeuwen & Venchi it is worth going out of the way for…
Steve Katz
.
21 Giugno 2026
10,0
I had an excellent experience at Anita Gelato on the Upper East Side. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with friendly and attentive service that made us feel welcome. The staff was patient, helpful, and happy to answer questions about the many flavors available.
The atmosphere is one of the highlights of this location. The décor is creative, vibrant, and full of character, making it much more than just a place to grab dessert. There is a warm family-friendly ambiance that makes it a great destination for families, couples, and friends looking to spend quality time together. The space is clean, inviting, and thoughtfully designed, creating a memorable experience from start to finish.
As for the gelato, it was exceptional. The Crème Brûlée flavor was incredibly rich and creamy with the perfect balance of sweetness, capturing the classic dessert beautifully. The Pistachio Kunafa was equally impressive, combining authentic pistachio flavor with the unique texture and taste inspired by traditional kunafa. Both flavors were fresh, flavorful, and among the best gelato options I have had.
Overall, Anita Gelato offers outstanding service, a beautiful atmosphere, and delicious desserts. Whether you are a local resident or visiting the Upper East Side, this is a place that deserves a visit. I look forward to returning and trying even more of their amazing flavors. Highly recommended!
Ery A
.
18 Giugno 2026
10,0
This was my first time visiting this place, and I was surprised by the long line—but it ended up being worth the experience. We tried the chocolate, strawberry, and crème brûlée flavors, and all were rich, creamy, and delicious. It is relatively expensive, so that’s something to keep in mind, but overall it was a fun and worthwhile treat.
Nazanin
.
17 Giugno 2026
10,0
Quality dessert spot that I appreciate because people with certain allergies/intolerances can find something fairly highly quality, would recommend if you are looking for a nice quick dessert spot in the city
Alix Aliyev
.
16 Giugno 2026
10,0
Gelato is fine but not great, prices are insane and the line is insane. Gentile across town is the best I’ve had outside of Italy. Go there.
Noah Halperin
.
13 Giugno 2026
6,0