It's been a while since we've been back to Gargotta, and I think it's changed management. In any case, we ate very well. Excellent steak, excellent tartare, even fried flowers, and amazing desserts. The appetizer platter was perhaps a bit ordinary, and they could use a makeover.
Excellent selection of wines and Prosecco. The terrace is perfect for summer evenings, with the background music of frogs that reminds us of the countryside. Discreet and informal service.
Elena Righini
.
09 Luglio 2025
8,0
Trattoria La Gargotta is a superb restaurant.
I went there for dinner with four friends.
We ate everything, a classic Tuscan/Florentine menu: classic Tuscan appetizer, first course (tagliolini with truffle), second course (grilled rosticciana), with side dishes (sautéed spinach and baked potatoes), and coffee.
Everything was VERY GOOD.
From start to finish.
The service was a bit awkward; they confused the bottle we ordered with a more expensive one.
The owner, having already opened it for us, apologized and offered it to us at the same price as the one we ordered. Truly very kind. (Not everyone would do that these days.)
The restaurant is located in the Florentine hills, just outside the city, with a splendid terrace overlooking the city, and a very beautiful and characteristic interior.
I highly recommend coming for dinner.
Federico Leonetti
.
08 Luglio 2025
10,0
Family dinner. We arrived early because we were leaving and suffered a lot from the heat. We asked for ice and bread several times, but were mistakenly taken to other tables. Glass of house wine served hot, undrinkable. Good Fiorentina, expensive first and second courses. 6 euros for a side of potatoes for 6 potato wedges. Stunning view from the terrace. Stunning sunset. As for the food, no, we wouldn't go back.
roxy roxy G.
.
07 Luglio 2025
8,0
The restaurant is located outside Florence, far from the chaos of the city, with a panoramic view, a nice atmosphere, kind and professional staff, and the dishes, all cooked in an excellent way. Highly recommended!!!
Ciro Carrea
.
04 Luglio 2025
10,0
Trattoria with a view of Florence. Found by chance on the internet and, given the reviews, we decided to have dinner here. Quiet place and excellent food. We opted for a Fiorentina and side dishes and we couldn't have made a better choice. Excellent cooking and normal price. Highly recommended.
Katiuscia Giussani
.
04 Luglio 2025
10,0
An exceptional place for a Tuscan meal is well worth it. Everything is perfect. It's simply incredible.
Lois Lemoine
.
04 Luglio 2025
10,0
Excellent restaurant specializing in Tuscan cuisine. Warm welcome, kindness, and professionalism.
I loved it.
JOELLE DENGHIEN
.
02 Luglio 2025
10,0
Excellent food, smart and smiling staff and owner who hosts you as if he had known you forever. The terrace is very suggestive.
Top experience
See you next time
Stefano Car
.
01 Luglio 2025
10,0
Abbiamo cenato in questo locale con un collega proprio sopra Firenze, in collina, la vista al tramonto è qualcosa di davvero molto suggestivo.. qualità dei piatti molto buona, rapporto qualità prezzo quindi direi ottimo, buona anche la lista vini, da tornarci.
Una conferma….sono stato a dicembre per il compleanno di mio figlio e sono tornato ora per il mio e devo dire che si mangia veramente bene con un rapporto qualità prezzo veramente di categoria assoluta. Il titolare è veramente all’altezza di tutto. Complimenti a chi sta in cucina e a chi si occupa della sala.
Non mancherò di tornare anche per lavoro.
Cristiano M
.
19 Gennaio 2025
8,0