The menu is extremely limited but considering it's a bar it's not surprising. However if they want to be a smokehouse they should advertise as a smokehouse so people know what kind of food they're getting. You walk into a cold lonely sad bar, the wait staff mostly ignores you. And all the food tastes like dirty fryer oil. I might try this place again but I was highly disappointed. Also, considering the quality of food you receive the prices are quite high. $50 for chicken tenders, french fries, a pulled pork sandwich, and potato chips from a bag was quite a bit.
Mr. Scratch
.
25 Ottobre 2025
6,0
Even if it’s the only game in town this time if year, it’s totally worth the trip across the pond!!
Kim Rae of Sunshine
.
24 Ottobre 2025
10,0
Friendly waiter and the food was great. I loved the crab bisque it had big pieces of crab and I could've drank a gallon of the broth
Brian Parsons
.
20 Ottobre 2025
10,0
Delicious BBQ, staff was very friendly and indoor and outdoor seating
Diane Graham
.
10 Ottobre 2025
10,0
Had the Mac burger, gf had the Mac with chicken. Was delicious. Service was also great. When I find myself on the Island again I’ll be going back.
Matthew Kutin
.
06 Ottobre 2025
10,0
Had a great day on the island and ended up here to eat. They have a great menu, the food we got was delicious. We came off season, end of September, and that is highly recommended by "me"
Greg G (G Squared)
.
04 Ottobre 2025
10,0
We finally got our 7 year late honeymoon trip and spent it on Block Island today. We did what we like to call "app hopping", where we go from restaurant to restaurant throughout the day trying 1 drink and 1 appetizer at each spot. We hit a few other places (Aldo's, Virginica's, McAloon's, Ballards) but were so fortunate to finally find PPP. Not only was our server, Alex amazing, but they are extremely peanut/tree nut friendly 🙏. The food is out of this world! Try the crab chowder, buff-a-que wings and smoked chicken wrap if you want a real treat. The drinks were phenomenal and the brown bag shot was a super fun, tasty surprise.
Bottom line, if you want a truly wonderful experience where you get great food, drinks, atmospehere and service, don't waste your time elsewhere. Come here and feel at home!
Betsy Gough
.
12 Settembre 2025
10,0
Punches way above its weight with food. Very good pizza. Read the specials board, always something interesting there! Curious. Tried to remove a fresh item from a special & told no changes to specials ! I get no changes, but no removes? Maybe think about your customer service.
Ravi Banerjee
.
31 Agosto 2025
10,0
The Pulled Pork Mac and Cheese was really good. I had seen so much live music when I had on other nights walked past, but somehow tonight, no. They did some type of mega Trivial Pursuit type game, with the whole place, and although it was not for me, the crowd did get into it.
Fun spot. Usual Block Island high prices/ compared to food level, but better than the average on that for Block Island.
Would return.
Richard Grasso
.
31 Agosto 2025
8,0
Went for our first trip to block island. This place was AMAZING. Very fair prices and the food was delicious. I had to order a second bowl of the crab chowder. The BBQ plate was more than enough for two people and everything on it was magnificent.
Steven
.
29 Agosto 2025
10,0