Fidalma In Sorano

03/08/2025: A real disappointment regarding the fish appetizer, I complained and they didn't charge me, but it was really low quality and not very fresh as regards the octopus! Very kind staff!

02/08/2025: It deserves 5 stars overall. Let's start with the truly charming location within the medieval center. Tables are arranged to the left of the walls, and despite the crowds passing by on the next street, they manage to leave you comfortable at your table because they're recessed and covered. The welcome was truly superb; the lady greeted us (reservation required) with a glass of prosecco. We sat down immediately and ordered four fish courses. The dishes were generous, excellent value for money. It's impossible to leave unsatisfied with the food. The catch of the day was truly fresh, as were the raw fish dishes we ordered by phone, which were truly superb and were fulfilled (not everyone!). The mixed fried fish was batter-light, so you could taste the flavors of the fish underneath. And then we moved on to the desserts... what can I say... all homemade by them. We had two cheesecakes that were totally unlike anything you've ever tasted. I don't know what spread they use, but it's creamy, not gelatinous, and even without the topping, it was superb. Definitely a place you MUST go if you want to eat well in Castiglione della Pescaia. I thank the entire staff for their helpfulness, and we congratulate them once again. A truly well-deserved 5 stars!