Enoteca degli Eretici In Monterotondo marittimo

14/09/2025: Let me start by saying that we ate very well; the dishes we ordered were truly excellent and of excellent quality. However, something went wrong with the bill, and so I asked for an explanation. I'll summarize: We ordered two platters of cured meats and cheeses chosen by the chef, two Maremma beef carpaccios (no sides as they were sold out), a bottle of water and a bottle of Fattorie di Magliano Morellino di Scansano DOCG 2020 wine, and two coffees. Finally, the waiter showed up with a bill of 102.50 (which became 102). I have the habit of occasionally doing the math in my head, just like that, due to my professional habits; something doesn't add up, and I ask for an explanation. The waiter panicked, trying everything to get close to the price but failing (he got to €99... although I don't know how he did it), making excuses that the platter wasn't €12 but €14 because there were cheeses (!!). He asked me if I'd included the service charge (which I confirmed... but he calculated it at €3.50 instead of €2.50). You can all get the actual bill by looking at the menu on their website: it comes out to €91 (including €5 for water, which is probably cheaper). I didn't ask for any money back; I left it as a tip. But I won't be back; for me, honesty is essential, as well as quality. Sorry. P.S.: Check your bill every now and then...

12/09/2025: Quiet location, spectacular meat, very good appetizers and first courses as well. Very professional and friendly staff. Highly recommended!!!