We've been there twice now (back to back). The first night, we ordered an appetizer platter to share, a splendid 1.2kg Florentine steak, and desserts (pannacotta and tiramisu), all truly excellent. Intrigued by the incredibly welcoming staff's commentary on various pizza competitions, we returned and tried it: it was also excellent, and it's hard to find a good pizza, with fresh dough and quality toppings! The photos speak for themselves.
A well-kept restaurant with a relaxed atmosphere.
Average prices (about €100 on the first night, and about €30 on the second night with pizzas and drinks for two).
Highly recommended.
Barbara A
.
08 Maggio 2026
10,0
You eat well and.....what a view.!!!
Massimo
.
11 Aprile 2026
10,0
Good food, quiet location, average price
Luca Grieco
.
11 Aprile 2026
8,0
Fantastic little place , the staff is lovely , good red wine and the food is great . We sampled the pizza and the pasta and came back a few times more .
Ramona Berchez
.
09 Aprile 2026
10,0
A great restaurant, lovely staff and the pasta was fabulous!
Faye Rowbury
.
16 Marzo 2026
10,0
This restaurant was recommended by our friend's mason, and it was fantastic. Easily he best meal we had on this one week trip to Tuscany.
The server (owner?) Sara, was attentive and her English was so fluent that our inability to speak Italian was not a barrier at all.
For primi, we had pici with mixed seafood, eggplant parmesan, and potato soup. For secondi, we had pasta with clams, octopus, and a platter of mixed cuts of pork, including a sausage made by Sara's father.
Each dish was arranged beautifully, as well.
Patrick McAloon
.
13 Marzo 2026
10,0
Excellent for both lunch and dinner (pizzas are only available at dinner). I've been coming here with family and friends for a while now, and we're never disappointed. The name "Castello" comes from its proximity to Montemassi Castle, just a short walk up the hill.
Domenico Vaiana
.
01 Marzo 2026
10,0
The atmosphere is welcoming and charming. Its proximity to the castle is ideal for a stroll. The first courses were excellent, as was the meat. The one I had, Angus ribs, was excessively fatty (like 1/4 meat, 3/4 fat). They say the fish is very good. I'll try it next time.
fast1lux Patrizia G.
.
06 Febbraio 2026
8,0
We ate very well and were looked after with care and courtesy, a place to discover.
Marco D'Agliano
.
31 Gennaio 2026
10,0
Nice place and very friendly and helpful staff.
Claudio l.
.
26 Dicembre 2025
10,0
Google
TripAdvisor