Trattoria Lemerle In

11/12/2023: Our visit started off rocky. When we arrived they did not have our reservation. Frustrating as it was a special occasion and I booked one of the special tables. I even showed them my confirmation and they were at a loss, but didn’t apologize once. No biggie, we got a nice table anyways. Couldn’t sit at the special tables because of the waves, but they sat us on the patio higher up as they were not busy. Food was good, but I ordered steak medium rare and it came back medium well… server never came to check on us and I wasn’t able to call them over so I couldn’t send it back. Ate it anyways and it was still good due to the amazing red wine sauce, but disappointing nonetheless as this was my honeymoon and I don’t splurge on filet often. We wanted to order another course of pasta, but as we couldn’t get our server anywhere near the table we ended up just getting our dessert when they finally came over to clear our plates (20 minutes after we had finished) then going to the bar. Again, they were not busy so I’m not sure what the reason for this was. Dessert was delicious. Management seemed unconcerned when we spoke to them, again disappointing. The bar was a different story. Excellent service from the bartender and excellent cocktails in a truly unique setting, a can’t miss.

16/11/2023: Not only were the food, ambience & views spectacular at il pirata, but Adnan was quite a site too! 😜 Not only is he an Italian Stallion, but he gave the best service with his nonstop beaming smile & positive energy that put us in the best mood! He went above and beyond & even walked 500 extra steps up & downhill when he was off duty just to help us out. He treated us like best friends/family from the moment we met him & truly epitomizes the warmth, joy & phenomenal hospitality that the Italians are known for. Make sure to request him & il Pirata please give him a raise, bonus & promotion! He deserves it! 💚🤍❤️ Fyi, the Seafood Pasta & Lobster Pasta were delicious! Also had the chocolate caprese torte with vanilla gelato & it was sooooo yummy! Almost as yummy as Adnan! 😄😋😘 Highly recommend il Pirata Restaurant, and not just because of Adnan!