The place is very beautiful, well-kept, and pleasant, and I really enjoyed the atmosphere.
Unfortunately, the food experience didn't entirely convince me. I think the prices are a bit high for what's on offer. The mini banana breads, in particular, weren't to my taste.
Toward the end, I also noticed a slight overkill in the food: since I was almost finished, I preferred not to report it immediately so as not to ruin the day, but it's still an unpleasant experience.
Overall, a nice place, but the quality-price ratio could be improved.
Failthy Zack
.
14 Gennaio 2026
6,0
We had a nice breakfast, the pancake with Nutella and banana 🥞 was very good and light and the place was very welcoming it was a nice experience
Mawada Ali
.
13 Gennaio 2026
8,0
4.5 ;)
The appetizers and cocktails were delicious, but my salmon was a bit dry. Impeccable service and a beautiful location.
Marie Gendrel
.
12 Gennaio 2026
8,0
Compliments to the place... but especially to the staff.
GIUSÈ: Yes, beautiful. ❤️
Giulia Caggiano (giuls)
.
11 Gennaio 2026
10,0
I visited La Menagere with my family. The location is exceptional, and the reception staff were very kind. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for the service, which was decidedly terrible and with virtually no customer service.
Our order was taken by a Spanish gentleman who didn't even look at us: he was unfriendly and surly, and every request he made was clearly annoyed.
On the other hand, the young man in the dining room, with a southern accent, was extremely kind and helpful: he went out of his way to make us feel comfortable, repeatedly asking if everything was okay and if he could do anything for us. He even accompanied us to the bathroom, while his colleague simply gave unclear directions.
Overall, the service didn't live up to the offerings or the prices.
Enzo Martoccia
.
09 Gennaio 2026
6,0
A place I adore. Super nice and helpful staff, congratulations indeed. The bathroom was absolutely stunning, it had to be said. The food was delicious, and I have to say I miss the "Tuna Shanghai" dish; it was incredibly good, and it should be brought back. Everything was unique and wonderful, congratulations.
Ambra F
.
08 Gennaio 2026
10,0
Shop in Shop concept, excellent
Jana Brodowski
.
07 Gennaio 2026
10,0
The place looks lovely, it’s not the italien osteria style, and we really liked that. We made a reservation in advance.
It’s modern, chic, but it was a bit cold inside probably because we sat on a long tabel close to a window. Becouse the tabel was long, we didn’t feel much the vibe of the place, if i would go back i would ask them for a different tabel.
The food was yummy, we loved that they didn’t have only the italien classic dishes.
The service was a bit slow, but understandable as we went at lunch time and the place was busy
Loredana Buta
.
04 Gennaio 2026
10,0
We had dinner at La Menagere.
Overall, it was disappointing, especially considering the very high prices.
The food itself was very good and well-prepared. We always received fresh bread, which was also very good and homemade.
The pasta dishes and my companion's salmon were excellent.
My filet mignon, unfortunately, wasn't cooked medium and came without any side dishes. The most annoying thing was that the foie gras, even though I had explicitly asked for it to be omitted, was still on the steak.
The service was generally inattentive, and things were often forgotten. This simply shouldn't happen at this price and level of service.
The ambiance is otherwise very nice, but the room temperature was too cold.
There are definitely much better restaurants in Florence at better prices.
Felix K
.
02 Gennaio 2026
8,0
A really lovely place, excellent breakfast, eggs Benedict, hot chocolate...
Beautiful interior setting...
A bit pricey for what you get, but an experience worth having.
Mathilde Trenaulay
.
01 Gennaio 2026
10,0