Il Gusto del Castellare In Montaione

24/09/2025: Arrived late at the restaurant at 10:25pm and they were super accommodating in letting us dine until we finished our dinner at 11:20pm. The service was awesome and they were very kind and attentive throughout even though we dined with them super late. Regarding the food, my family did the Florentine steak course for 2 meal. When they brought out the steak, I thought it was HUGE! After eating the steak, I thought it was one of the best steaks I’ve had coming from Los Angeles. It was NOT well done at all like other reviews have said. It came out rare and perfectly cooked in my opinion. The course also came with dessert which was a nice way to close out the steak. The dessert tasted light, not overly sweet or heavy which was a nice way to close out our dinner after having eaten so much steak. We also ordered a cream gnocchi which was alright, but nothing to write home about. It was little cheesy for my personal taste but it was still good nonetheless. Your mileage will vary depending on how much you like cheese. Overall I thought their steak course deal was amazing at $55 for two people considering how much other places charge. I was skeptical reading the reviews at first but I recommend anyone who’s on the fence to give this place a try!

22/09/2025: Good Italian food, the dishes are adequate and sufficient, good service