My boyfriend and I fell in love with this place which is very close to our apartment, and we go there every week after yoga-class. The staff is very friendly, the pizza is the best we have found in Florence so far (especially La Sorrentina), and the atmosphere of the place is so lovely. It is a very small place, so most people get take out, but there are a few tables if you want to dine there. They are only open for a few hours of the day, and it is very popular so the wait can be a little long (up untill 25 min). However, if the temperature is nice, you can get a drink and enjoy it outside while you wait for the food.
https://no.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g187895-d7353087-r941183141-Casa_Della_Pizza-Florence_Tuscany.html#